Restaurant books are different from every other small business I keep, and not because restaurants are complicated. It is because the margins are thin enough that a two-point swing in food cost is the difference between a good year and closing, and most owners find out which one they had in April. I am Josh Katz, a CPA in Beachwood, and this is how I set up and run the books for restaurants, cafes, bars, and food trucks across Cleveland and the east side, with the Ohio sales tax, tip, and municipal rules that generic restaurant accounting advice skips.
Related reading: how much a bookkeeper costs in Cleveland.
Start with prime cost, not profit
The number a Cleveland restaurant owner should see every week is prime cost: food and beverage cost plus total labor including payroll taxes, divided by sales. Full-service restaurants that last run prime cost around 60 to 65 percent; quick service and counter concepts can get into the mid 50s. If you only see this number at tax time, you have no lever to pull. The books have to be organized to produce it weekly, which means the chart of accounts, the POS export, and the payroll report all have to line up with the same week.
The chart of accounts that makes prime cost possible
Sales split at minimum into food, beer and wine, liquor, non-alcoholic beverages, catering, and merchandise, because each carries different tax treatment and different margins. Cost of goods sold split the same way, so food cost and pour cost show separately. Labor split into kitchen, front of house, management, and payroll taxes and benefits. Everything else is overhead: occupancy, utilities, marketing, repairs, delivery platform fees, credit card fees. Most QuickBooks restaurant files I inherit have a single “Sales” line and a single “Cost of Goods,” and that is why the owner cannot tell whether the problem is the bar or the kitchen.
Daily sales from the POS, not from the bank
The bank deposit is not your sales figure. It is sales, minus credit card fees, minus tips paid out, minus cash kept for the drawer, plus or minus whatever the processor batched that day, arriving two days late. Record a daily sales entry from the POS report (Toast, Square, Clover all export it) that captures gross sales by category, sales tax collected, tips, discounts and comps, and the split between cash and cards. Then match the card deposits and the cash deposits to that entry when they hit the bank. Done this way, sales tax, tips, and fees are all correct automatically, and the week’s revenue is known on Monday morning instead of whenever the bank catches up.
Ohio sales tax on food: the rule most owners get backwards
Ohio exempts food sold for consumption off the premises. That means carry-out and delivery food is generally not taxed, while the same meal eaten in the dining room is taxed at the Cuyahoga County rate of 8 percent. Soft drinks, alcohol, and anything sold for consumption on the premises are taxable regardless. Catering is taxable. The POS has to be configured to apply tax by order type, and the bookkeeping has to reconcile the tax collected to the sales tax return each month. The two common errors are charging tax on carry-out (which overcharges customers and still has to be remitted) and failing to tax dine-in drinks. Sales tax returns are due on the 23rd of the following month, filed through the Ohio Business Gateway.
Tips: reporting, allocation, and the credit most restaurants leave on the table
Three tip rules matter. First, employees must report tips to you, and you withhold payroll taxes on them; the POS tip report is your record. Second, if reported tips fall below 8 percent of gross receipts, you have to allocate the shortfall to employees on their W-2s and file Form 8027 if you are a large food or beverage establishment (more than ten employees on a typical day). Third, and most valuable, the FICA tip credit on Form 8846 gives the business a credit for the employer Social Security and Medicare tax paid on tips above the minimum wage threshold. For a full-service restaurant with a $400,000 tip pool, that credit can run $25,000 to $30,000 a year. It only works if tips are tracked correctly in the books all year.
Inventory counts and the food cost calculation
True food cost needs a beginning inventory, purchases, and an ending inventory for the period. Weekly or at least monthly counts of the walk-in, dry storage, and the bar, entered as an inventory adjustment, turn “purchases this month” into “what we actually used.” Without counts, a big delivery on the 30th makes a good month look terrible and the next month look great, and you learn nothing. Most of my restaurant clients count the bar weekly and food monthly; the bar is where variance hides.
Delivery platforms and third-party fees
DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub deposit net amounts after commissions of 15 to 30 percent. Record the gross order as sales and the commission as an expense, not the net deposit as sales. Otherwise your food cost percentage is overstated, your sales are understated, and your sales tax (which the platforms now generally collect and remit as marketplace facilitators in Ohio) does not reconcile. Each platform publishes a monthly statement; it should be entered like a POS report.
Payroll, the Ohio way
Ohio’s minimum wage for tipped employees is a bit over half the full minimum, with the tip credit making up the difference, and both figures adjust each January. Payroll taxes are usually the largest single expense after food, so the books should carry employer taxes, workers’ comp (through the Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation, which is mandatory and state-run), and unemployment as part of labor cost, not buried in overhead. If any employee is paid partly in cash, stop; the cash is still wages, still taxable, and it is the most common reason a restaurant audit goes badly.
Municipal tax: where the restaurant sits and where the staff live
A restaurant in Cleveland files its net profit return and withholds employee city tax through CCA. A restaurant in Cleveland Heights, Shaker Heights, Beachwood, or most of the east-side suburbs does the same through RITA. Employees who live in a different city than they work may owe tax to both, with a credit that varies by city. Your payroll provider handles the withholding if you set up the city codes correctly at hiring; the books have to carry the city liabilities separately so the quarterly reconciliations tie out. The rules and a rate table for 31 cities are in my RITA and CCA guide.
Liquor: permits, pour cost, and the state
Bars and restaurants with an Ohio liquor permit have an extra set of records to keep: the permit itself renews annually with the Division of Liquor Control, spirits are purchased through state agency stores at fixed prices, and beer and wine come from licensed distributors. Pour cost (liquor cost divided by liquor sales) should run 18 to 24 percent; if the books show 30, either the pricing is off or product is walking out the door. Separate beer, wine, and liquor sales and costs so you can see which.
Occupancy and the lease
Rent is often the second largest fixed cost. Many Cleveland leases carry percentage rent, common area charges, and real estate tax pass-throughs that are billed annually and hit the books as one large surprise. Accrue them monthly. If you have made leasehold improvements, they belong on the balance sheet and get depreciated over the lease term, which is a meaningful deduction that disappears if the improvements were expensed as “repairs.”
What good restaurant books look like each week
- Daily sales entries from the POS, matched to card and cash deposits
- Prime cost report: food, beverage, and labor as a percentage of sales
- Bar inventory count entered; food count at least monthly
- Delivery platform statements entered gross with commissions as expense
- Tip report reconciled to payroll
- Sales tax collected reconciled to the POS by order type
And each month: every bank and card account reconciled, vendor bills entered and aged, payroll liabilities tied to the payroll reports, RITA or CCA withholding and estimates checked, and a profit and loss by category that the owner reads in ten minutes.
What it costs to have this done
My monthly bookkeeping for restaurants starts at $350 a month, flat, and most single-location restaurants with one POS and one payroll provider land between $350 and $650 depending on volume and whether weekly prime cost reporting is included. Tax returns are separate and quoted in advance: business returns from $1,500, individual from $800. If the books are behind, the catch-up is a one-time project; here is how that works and what it costs.
Frequently asked questions
Is carry-out food taxable in Ohio? Generally no. Food sold for consumption off the premises is exempt. Dine-in food, soft drinks, alcohol, and catering are taxable. Your POS must apply tax by order type.
What is a good food cost percentage for a Cleveland restaurant? Food cost of 28 to 35 percent is typical for full service; the more useful number is prime cost (food plus labor) under about 65 percent.
Do I have to file Form 8027? If you are a food or beverage establishment where tipping is customary and you normally had more than ten employees on a typical business day in the prior year, yes, annually. It also feeds the 8 percent allocation rule.
Can you work with Toast or Square? Yes. Both export daily sales by category and both can connect to QuickBooks Online or Xero. The setup is the first thing I fix.
Josh Katz, CPA, 3401 Enterprise Pkwy, Suite 340-387, Beachwood, OH 44122. Call (216) 249-6013 for a free consultation.
Want these books kept for you?
Monthly bookkeeping for Cleveland small businesses starts at $350, flat, with a CPA doing the work.